During the pandemic, the lack of low-threshold activities and safe spaces, decreased access to supportive adults and emotional support, fewer opportunities for personal development through social interaction and meaningful participation in activities with other young people. This led to a loss of togetherness that may have left irreparable gaps in young people’s well-being, socialisation processes, and social skills.
In the event of future crises, the priority should be to ensure the strategic supply of these resilience factors throughout the leisure sector rather than merely ensuring that leisure activities continue. This study suggests paying particular attention to the resilience factors presented in Figure 4.2.
Togetherness and social interaction
One of the young interviewees provided a practical example of how a sense of togetherness and social interaction was lacking in his music classes and elsewhere during the pandemic. He pointed out that offering lessons online is valuable, but it would be even better if the orchestra could have continued to provide a sense of togetherness. The interviewee stated:
‘When you play music, you want to hear others. During the pandemic, no orchestra rehearsals were possible, and group activities were suspended. That was much less fun. You lose the human relationship and contact. The sense of community is compromised, and you feel distant from others.’
The interviewee reflected on the idea that social interaction can be cultivated through conscious effort:
‘I would have liked more opportunities to chat with others about our shared experiences. I even lost my social skills during the pandemic. Youth workers can help by bringing everyone together and starting conversations, not only during a crisis but in general.’
The experience of this young interviewee reflects the findings of this report, shedding light on how the conscious and strategic design of methods and activities can strengthen various resilience factors to varying degrees. One measure that reportedly fostered togetherness and emotional support during the pandemic was setting aside time at the start of an activity for check-in sessions. Looking to the future, one way to further strengthen key resilience factors in music classes, for instance, would be to combine music schools with youth clubs where youth workers are available before and after lessons. Togetherness could be promoted by providing group activities, orchestras for example. Young musicians could be encouraged to participate more meaningfully by being given the opportunity to collaborate on their own project, such as organising their own concert. A similar conscious development process could take place for other types of activities.
One of the young interviewees, who has a neurodivergent diagnosis, emphasised that what she missed most during the pandemic was the opportunity to spend time with and interact with other young people. She said:
‘I missed my Scouts for six months. I was sad and bored. I spent most of my time in bed scrolling through my phone. I missed going out into the forest with my friends. I missed my friends a lot.’
The interviewee describes just how challenging it can be for neurodivergent people to motivate themselves and emphasises the importance of young people having access to social platforms and experience togetherness:
‘Due to my condition, I find it hard to do quiet activities on my own, like painting. I can’t focus on one activity for long. In the Scouts, however, we do a variety of activities, so you don’t get bored. While we’re doing an activity, we talk and interact with each other.’
Low-threshold inclusion
Another resilience factor emphasised throughout the report is access to ‘low-threshold inclusion’. As demonstrated in the report, young people with fewer opportunities are more vulnerable to the negative effects of a crisis. It is therefore vital to minimise barriers to participation in leisure activities, as these young people have a lower threshold for participation due to factors such as a lack of parental support and financial resources. They may also experience discrimination and have health issues and a low self-esteem.
A dance teacher described how young people with mental health issues were the first to be excluded by digitalisation. This illustrates the consequences of raising the participation threshold through activity adaptations in a crisis.
Another interviewee, a young volunteer in civil society organisations, emphasised the importance of lowering these barriers even further:
‘We should remember that we are dealing with vulnerable individuals. Some of them may have been isolated from social contexts for a long time. They suffer from social anxiety and may find leisure activities extremely stressful. So, even if some activities have to be cancelled, those who organise them must learn to be more creative and patient, both during the crisis and when the activities resume. People might not show up at first, but if you are persistent, they eventually will.’
The same interviewee suggested that an effective measure during the pandemic was to be approachable and maintain a welcoming attitude, despite the irregular participation of some young people. Another advice was to continue activities on fixed days at fixed times to keep the threshold low.
Several informants emphasised the importance of keeping youth clubs open, as these provide a low-threshold entry point to leisure activities for young people who are not currently participating. The permanent and local nature of the clubs, and the relationships formed with supportive youth workers, are difficult to replicate in a digital youth work setting.
Maintaining resilience factors in digitalised leisure
Another area that requires further consideration regarding resilience factors is the digitalisation of leisure activities. In the event of future crises, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, digitalisation will provide ample opportunities for the leisure sector to continue many of its activities online. Therefore, it is highly relevant to explore the potential of digitalisation while maintaining resilience factors such as active participation, togetherness, and access to supportive adults. Further research in this area, practical toolkits, and competence building would all be highly valuable going forward.